CONTRA COSTA COUNTY  
1025 ESCOBAR STREET  
MARTINEZ, CA 94553  
Meeting Minutes  
Thursday, July 17, 2025  
6:00 PM  
1025 Escobar St., Room 110  
Martinez  
Webinar ID: 990 1981 7954  
Passcode: 228815  
Library Commission  
- Hard copy agenda packets are available for viewing at each Contra Costa County Library  
- The Library Commission will provide reasonable accommodations for persons with  
disabilities planning to attend Library Commission meetings who contact Library  
Administration at least 72 hours before the meeting, at (925) 608-7700. After 72 hours prior,  
accommodations will be on a best-efforts basis.  
Any disclosable public records related to an open session item on a regular meeting agenda  
and distributed by the Contra Costa County Library Commission to a majority of members of  
the Library Commission less than 96 hours prior to that meeting are available for public  
inspection at Contra Costa County Library Administration, 777 Arnold Drive, Suite 210,  
Martinez, CA 94553.  
Library Commissioners, please call Library Administration, at (925) 608-7700 by 5 p.m.  
Wednesday, July 16th if you will NOT be at the meeting. A quorum must be established  
in-person before a meeting can be held. A record is maintained of Commissioner’s attendance.  
1.  
CALL THE MEETING TO ORDER / ROLL CALL  
Chair Nicole Gemmer called the meeting to order at 6:05pm. Walt Beveridge took roll and with 13  
voting members present, a quorum was established.  
Jim Dexter, Robin Eckert, Nicole Gemmer, Marina Hsieh,  
Heather Lurvey, Richard Means, Amit Prayag, Robert  
Sanguedolce, Linda Sendig, Tommy Smith, Bryan Thomas,  
and Bethany Woods  
Present  
Julia Dozier, Sue Hamill, Zelda LeFrak-Belleci, Dennisha  
Marsh, Robert Mason, Frederick Page, and Rachel Rosekind  
Excused  
Absent  
Matt DeFraga, Vivian Faye, Shrikant Garde, Stacie Hinton,  
Anne Kingsley, Amenda Kung, Lynn Mackey, Jo Ellen  
Marcotte, George Pursley, and Donna Rennie  
2.  
WELCOME & INTRODUCTIONS  
Chair Gemmer introduced several new commissioners who each took a moment to say a few words  
about themselves.  
3.  
PUBLIC COMMENT  
No members of the public were present at this meeting.  
4.  
Attachments:  
With 13 "Aye" votes and one abstention, the motion to accept the 5-15-2025 meeting  
minutes as they were presented was passed.  
Motion:  
Hsieh  
Second:  
Prayag  
5.  
Attachments:  
County Librarian Alison McKee highlighted several items in her written report to the  
commission then called for any questions. No one had any so the meeting continued.  
6.  
COMMISSIONER WORK PLAN ACTION ITEMS (Report Out / Current Events)  
Commissioner Fitzpatrick: In his previous role as a Oakley Commissioner, Arnold was involved in  
fundraising efforts for the Clayton Library. He also has been attending programs there to show  
support.  
Commissioner Prayag: Amit had 3 items to report. 1. He attended a Clayton Foundation meeting to  
report on the May Commission meeting to the group; 2. Amit and his family participated in the  
Clayton 4th of July parade to show support; 3. Amit has joined the Clayton Foundation  
Communication Sub-Committee and they are now reviewing the Library Marketing Plan for both the  
Foundation and the Clayton Library.  
7.  
AGENDA SETTING FOR NEXT MEETING and FUTURE TOPICS  
Commissioner Swernoff suggested an update on efforts regarding a new library for El Cerrito.  
Alison stated that she thought that was more of a city function than an item for the full commission  
and suggest that Commissioner Swernoff might huddle with Commissioner Fischer from El Cerrito  
to speak about this topic.  
8.  
Attachments:  
Alison's PowerPoint slides are attached to these minutes.  
Self-service Sundays Pilot Results  
WORKING COMMITTEE REPORTS  
Attachments:  
9.  
Commissioner Lurvey provided the report this meeting due to Commissioner Dozier being absent:  
Legislative Update  
California  
In June, Governor Newsom signed the 2025 State Budget Bill. California State Library Parks Pass  
program was funded through 2026-it had been subject to end in 2025 due to an $6.75 million budget  
cut proposed in the legislature’s budget plan earlier this year. The California State Parks Foundation  
obtained over 8,000 signatures supporting the program. The funds are appropriated for the State  
Parks & Rec Fund, not directly to the libraries. $3.6 million was allocated to the Altadena Library  
District. The libraries in Altadena were damaged by the fires earlier this year. The Library District  
expects to receive reduced funding from property taxes for the next few years due to the widespread  
loss of homes and property damage. The governor stated the State of California would not be able to  
replace the funds IMLS had provided to California.  
Federal  
No library-related bills in Congress right now.  
In FCC v. Consumers’ Research and SHLB v. Consumers' Research decided in June, the Supreme  
Court held the Universal Service Fund, which encompasses the E-Rate program which subsidizes  
internet connectivity for libraries, is constitutional, overturning the Fifth Circuit. ALA v. Sonderling  
and State of Rhode Island v. Trump, two lawsuits challenging the administration’s Executive Order  
14238, are pending in federal courts.  
10.  
CORRESPONDENCE  
Walter reported that the only correspondence since the previous meeting had to do with information  
relating to how an interested person could apply for an open spot on the commission. Walter referred  
the inquiry to the appropriate city clerk and the person asking was sent an application and a  
description of the process involved.  
11.  
COMMISSIONER ANNOUNCEMENTS  
Commissioner Hsieh shared that the San Ramon Pedestrian Bridge over Highway 680 was opening  
on Saturday July 19th and there would be a pop-up book sale by the Friends along the path of the  
walk. She also mentioned that the Dougherty Station Library would shortly be celebrating its 20th  
anniversary and for a $20 donation, yard signs celebrating the library were available to the public.  
12.  
ADJOURNMENT to the Thursday, September 18, 2025, LIBRARY COMMISSION  
MEETING.  
Chair Gemmer adjourned the meetng at 7:33 pm.